Dataquest Insight: Software Support Portfolios,
Oracle, North America, 2007 Update

 
21 December 2007

Bob Igou

Gartner Dataquest Research Note G00153267
 

Company profiles and software support portfolios will be presented for 33 software support providers in this series of reports. The software support services revenue of just 24 of these companies represents 30% of the worldwide software support services market of $48 billion.





Table of Contents



    
What You Need to Know

    
Introduction

    
Analysis

    
Findings
    
Recommendations

    
For Service Providers
    
For User Organizations
    
Methodology and Definitions

    
Study Objectives
    
Methodology
    
Support Offering Definition
    
Oracle Company Overview Profile and Support Portfolio
    
Support Portfolio Survey Model Review

    
Introduction
    
Pricing Methods and Terms
    
Offering Coverage and Availability
    
Support Provider Response Parameters
    
Products Supported
    
Access to Support Center
    
Incident Communications Media
    
Software Updates
    
On-Site Technical Support
    
Account Management
    
Entitled Internet-Based Services
    
On-Site Professional Services
    
Training and Education Components of Support Portfolios


List of Tables



Table 1.  
Oracle Company Overview
 

Table 2.  
Oracle Software Support Offerings (Part 1)
 

Table 3.  
Oracle Software Support Offerings (Part 2)
 

What You Need to Know



Product support services consume a large portion of the IT budget for companies of all sizes. Worldwide, spending on software support services represents 16.5% of the amount spent by IT organizations on software according to a Gartner survey done in 2006 ("User Survey Analysis: Infrastructure Support Services Software Base Budget, Worldwide, 2006-2007").

This report provides the details of Oracle's software support portfolio and aspects of its software maintenance and support business.

Insight from this report can be used by software support providers when constructing or revising their support portfolios. Insight from this report can also be used by IT professionals that evaluate, procure and/or manage software support contracts from external service providers (ESPs).






Introduction



Previous versions of the Gartner Software Support Portfolio Review consisted of two reports to cover two categories of ESPs so that the comparison of the support offerings was on more-equal footing. The two categories were computer hardware OEMs with software support offerings and software publishers. Beginning this year, a separate portfolio review report will be published for each vendor. This series of reports will examine the support portfolios of 33 vendors. See "Report Highlight for Dataquest Insight: Software Support Portfolios, North America, 2007 Update" for links to the other support portfolios that have been published to date.

The trends and analysis revealed in this report provide valuable information to software support service product and marketing managers and to service delivery line managers in ESP organizations. This document addresses the following critical issues:

  • What services, customers and markets offer the best opportunities for my business?
  • What are the best packaging, pricing and delivery models for the established services portfolio?
  • What should I do about market dynamics and competitors that could endanger my business?

This report is also valuable to IT professionals that evaluate, procure and/or manage software support contracts from ESPs.






Analysis




Findings

Overall, the changes from the previous year to this year represent a small net change, but significant shifts occurred within individual vendors. This modicum of change represents a mature, but active, industry, in which vendors are willing to make shifts to better accommodate the needs and wants of their customers. Technology user organizations continue to be under considerable budget pressure, and customers are negotiating hard on the price of their support contracts. In response, support executives are looking for ways to add value to options in their support portfolios.

Support providers alter their portfolios for the following main reasons:

  • The need to integrate an acquisition into a new portfolio of offerings to serve the needs of the combined product family and customer base
  • Building out the portfolio into a continuum of offerings that better serve the customer base
  • Augmenting offerings to add additional features, such as account management, or to serve a focused market, such as mission-critical applications

Compared with the previous portfolio review, Oracle altered its support portfolio as follows:

  • It retained its two support offerings from 2006: Oracle Premier Support and Advanced Customer Service.
  • Oracle added three new support offerings to support its Linux distribution: Enterprise Linux Network Support, Enterprise Linux Basic Support and Enterprise Linux Premier Support.
  • Oracle has added a new support offering to support its Oracle VM product, Oracle VM Premier Support.

Despite Oracle's aggressive acquisitions, it has kept its support portfolio exceptionally lean, adding offerings only to deliver support for Linux and Oracle VM. Based on previous acquisitions, Gartner believes that long-term, Oracle is unlikely to add future offerings related to specific acquisitions.

New players appeared in the 2007 review to cater to new needs in the software support services market. These include companies that provide support services for open-source software and third-party software support providers. By third party, we mean vendors that are not aligned with or partners with the original software publisher.




Recommendations

For Service Providers

Software support providers have continued to evolve their support portfolios in response to customer and market demand. The following five areas need continual improvement:

  • Focus on total time to resolution. Some vendors are thinking of this, but none have brought offerings to market.
  • Develop portfolios so offerings exist that are affordable to small and midsize businesses. This market segment has fewer IT resources to devote to support and cannot afford offerings designed for large enterprises.
  • Market portfolio offerings and features so that investments in support of automation technology and integrated incident reporting and response media will see fruition. The lack of such marketing assures that investments will be underutilized.
  • As with support automation technologies, support providers must actively communicate the features available from support offerings, especially now, when the user emphasis is on the value of the offering.
  • The buyers of support contracts are far less likely to be the same people that use the agreements. This places an additional burden on support providers to find and communicate to the people that are the users of the agreements.



For User Organizations

IT support services procured from ESPs continue to consume a large portion of the IT budget. User organizations are advised to inventory their application and infrastructure to determine the scope of users for each software product, the importance to the business and the availability requirements for each software product. Review established support agreements, and apply changes consistently with the importance and availability requirements of each product set.

Software support providers continue to evolve their portfolios of support offerings. Users must be vigilant in understanding what e-support offerings are available from their providers because these deliver more-efficient and more-effective support. These portfolios offer more flexibility and choice than in previous years. Users of software support must study the offerings of their ESPs and determine what level of support offering provides the features they need at a rate that is affordable by the organization.




Methodology and Definitions

Study Objectives

This series of reports presents the full software support portfolios of software publishers with software support offerings. This report does not attempt to encompass all the software vendors in the market, but the vendors covered do provide a solid representation of the market. This report covers the software support offerings of Linux distribution vendors, independent software support providers, software publishers and independent software vendors. The software support offerings of hardware OEMs with software support offerings will be covered in a separate series of nine reports.

The objectives of this study were to identify and highlight key software support portfolio deliverables that are available from software companies. The following companies were surveyed by the software support portfolio research team:

  • Adobe
  • Aspect Software
  • Avaya
  • BEA Systems
  • BMC Software
  • Callidus Software
  • Cisco
  • Dell
  • EMC
  • Fujitsu
  • HP
  • IBM
  • IFS
  • Infosys Technologies
  • Lawson
  • McAfee
  • Microsoft
  • NEC
  • NetSuite
  • Novell
  • OpenLogic
  • Oracle
  • Red Hat
  • RightNow Technologies
  • Rimini Street
  • Salesforce.com
  • SAP
  • SGI
  • Software AG
  • Sun
  • Sybase
  • Symantec
  • TomorrowNow

At the time of publishing this report, some of these companies may not have completed their submission for the portfolio review.




Methodology

Support service representatives at each of the companies that provide software support were sent a survey with tables for capturing their company demographics and support portfolios. Results were compiled from each completed survey and from other published resources. The major offerings of these service companies provide a solid representative sampling of software support services available in the industry. In some instances, the companies that responded to the survey did not include every offering or variation they provide.

The survey instruments were primarily two sets of tables: one for company overview information and the other for cataloging the company's support portfolio. Gartner publishes the company overview and support portfolio exactly as received from the vendor and makes only minor formatting changes.




Support Offering Definition

Support offerings are branded services packaged for purchase and subsequent entitlement to delivery of IT software product support. "Branded" means it must be marketed with the seller's name (with consideration of some type of monetary transaction that may include the purchase of a product or a renewal of an established service). "Purchase" means it must be purchased in consideration for a fee; it is not a product guarantee or usability warranty. "Product support" indicates a technology's cumulative knowledge store and dissemination mechanisms regarding defect mediation and usage questions. "Subsequent entitlement to delivery" indicates that, after the transaction, the buyer has the right to access support services.




Oracle Company Overview Profile and Support Portfolio

This section contains a company overview table (Table 1) and the details of Oracle's support offerings (Tables 2 and 3). Table 1 has sections that provide the following:

  • The scope of the company's support operations
  • The range of products for which support is offered
  • Sales and marketing practices for support services
  • Policy about software maintenance (software license updates and upgrades)
  • Warranty policy

Tables 2 and 3 have sections that provide the following:

  • Pricing methods and terms
  • Offering coverage and availability
  • Vendor response parameters
  • Products supported
  • Access to support centers
  • Incident communication media
  • Software updates
  • On-site support provisions
  • Account management
  • Entitled Internet-based services
  • On-site professional services (included with the offering)
  • Training and education services (included with the offering)

Table 1. Oracle Company Overview

Oracle Overview
Overview
Notes and Comments
Year Founded
1977
 
Total Company Revenue
$18 billion
Fiscal year 2006 (June 2006 to May 2006)
Total Services Revenue (All Services)
$12.11 billion
 
Total Support Revenue
$8.54 billion
 
Number of Support Centers Worldwide
18
Access to 24/7 real-time support for mission-critical issues through our Global Support Center. Eighteen major hubs on five continents.
Major Geographical Regions of Services Business
Global
 
Software Product Market Focus
Applications, infrastructure, database
 
Hardware Product Market Focus
NA
 
Operating Systems Supported
Unix, Windows, NT, Linux, mainframe other proprietary
 
Linux Distributions Supported
Oracle Enterprise Linux, Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Novell SUSE Enterprise Linux, Asianux
 
Oracle's major products are certified on the noted Linux distributions. In addition, Oracle offers Oracle Unbreakable Linux, a support program that provides support offerings specifically for Linux; it is not a Linux distribution. Oracle refers to the Red Hat compatible distribution it provides as Oracle Enterprise Linux. As part of Unbreakable Linux Support Program, Oracle supports both established Red Hat Enterprise Linux implementations, as well as Oracle Enterprise Linux implementations.
Organizational Reporting for Support Services
Executive vice president manages worldwide support operations, On Demand (outsourcing), and Oracle University. Vice president reports directly to the CEO
 
Support Services Financial Model
Profit and loss center
 
Local Language Capabilities of Support Contact Center
27
 
Internationalization of Support Information and Web Content
27
 
Support Sales and Marketing Practices
Who Sells Technical Support Initially?
License sales force,
Support sales force
 
Who Sells Technical Support Renewals?
Support sales force
 
Support Attachment Rate
99%
 
Support Contract Renewal Rate
Not published
 
Support Contracts Automatically Renew
No
 
Method for Terms of Software Support Policy
No specific number of versions. Products all have defined support time frames defined in the Lifetime Support policy. Major Oracle branded products released post-September 2005 receive 5 years of Premier Support and indefinite Sustaining Support. Specifically defined releases an additional 3 years of Extended Support
 
Boundaries of Software Support Policy
60 months full support all products falling under Premier Support, indefinite Sustaining Support.
 
Terms for Out-of-Policy Support
No
 
Fee Basis for Out-of-Policy Support
With Lifetime Support, products are always supported, there is no "Out-of-policy" support. During Extended Support, if the customer would like to purchase the service, it is priced as follows: Year 1 a 10% uplift over Premier Support, Years 2 and 3 a 20% uplift over Premier Support.
 
Support Services Discounted
Yes
 
Resellers Sell Support Services
Yes
 
Resellers Sell Consulting Services
NA
 
Resellers Sell Most-Comprehensive Support Program
Resellers sell Premier Support/Referrals paid on Advanced Support and On Demand
 
Pricing Basis for Support and Maintenance
Net price of software
 
Software Maintenance (Updates and Upgrades)
Maintenance Purchase Options
Maintenance bundled with support offerings
 
Maintenance Available Without Purchasing Support?
No
 
Software Maintenance Pricing Method
Percentage of net software license price
 
Pricing Strategy for Contract Renewals
The renewal fee is the support price from last year plus the inflationary adjustment rate. Fees are increased annually by the inflationary adjustment factor of, currently 3%, for contracts in U.S. dollars and for those in a foreign currency, the local renewal adjustment calculation is used either 3% or 4% to adjust for fluctuations in currency.
 
 
Pricing Terms for Renewals
If renewed for the same number of licenses for the same programs, for the first and second renewal years the fee will not increase by more than 5% over the prior year's fee.
 
Discounts for Multiyear Contracts
NA
 
Warranty Policies
Software Warranty Provided
Yes
 
Incidents Covered by Warranty
Material failure to perform according to program documentation
 
Term of Warranty
12 months
 
Type of Support Provided by Warranty
All
 
Hours of Operation for Warranty Support
24/7
 
NA = not applicable
N/A = not available

Source: Gartner (November 2007)

 


 



Table 2. Oracle Software Support Offerings (Part 1)



Offering Name

Oracle Premier Support
Advanced Customer Service

Oracle VM Premier Support

Notes for Oracle VM Premier Support
 
Oracle Software Support
 
Pricing Method and Terms
Standard Price of Offering
22% of net
Custom price
Calculated on a per-system basis
 
Price Range
NA
NA
$499 and $2,997 (refer to Notes for Oracle VM Premier Support)
Oracle VM Premier Support (1 Year) Annual price per system with up to 2 physical CPUs (sockets) is $499. Annual price per system with unlimited physical CPUs is $999 Oracle VM Premier Support (3 Years) Annual price per system with up to 2 physical CPUs is $1,497; and annual price per system with unlimited physical CPU's is $2,997.
Pricing Method
Percentage of net software license
Varies by systems, product, named users, and so on
Refer to Notes for Oracle VM Premier Support.
Calculated on a per-system basis.
1. Annual price per system with up to two physical CPUs
2. Annual price per system with unlimited physical CPUs
Price Basis
Net price of software
NA
NA
 
Term of Contract
Annual contract
Annual contract
Annual contract
1 year or 3 year standard terms.
Available on Per-Call or Per-Incident Basis
No
No
No
 
Offering Coverage and Availability
Primary Features — Technical Support
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Percentage of Customers Using Technical Support Offering
100%
5% or less
N/A
 
Scope of Products Covered
All products
Flexible; ranges from single instance to all products across enterprise.
Oracle VM
 
Intended Audience
IT staff, end users, partners, developers
IT staff, partners, developers
IT staff, end users, partners
 
Mission-Critical-Level Support
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Hours of Coverage
24/7
24/7
24/7
 
After-Hours Coverage
included
included
included
 
Geographical Availability
Global
Global
Global
 
Uplift for Additional Regions
No
No
No
 
Prerequisites Before Purchase
No
Oracle Premier Support
No
 
Offering Mandatory for New License
No, but highly recommended
No
No
 
Term for Mandatory Support
Not mandatory
NA
Not mandatory
 
Vendor Response Parameters
Time to First Technical Response
Less than 1 hour
< 60 minutes
Less than 1 hour
 
Emergency Response Time
Less than 1 hour
< 10 minutes
Less than 1 hour
 
Emergency Response Hours of Action
24/7
24/7
24/7
 
Contractual SLAs Available
No
Yes
No
 
Products Supported
 
 
 
 
Enterprise Applications
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Desktop/Client Applications
No
No
No
 
Infrastructure Software
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Server Software
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Operating Systems
 
 
 
 
Linux OS
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
All Other OS
Yes
Yes
No
 
Hardware
No
No
No
 
Network
No
No
No
 
Access to Support Center
Number of Named Callers
Identified technical contacts. Number of contacts determined by annual support fee.
Identified technical contacts
Identified technical contacts
 
Number of Incidents
Unlimited
Unlimited
Unlimited
 
Priority Queue
No
Yes
No
 
Advanced Support Queue
Product-specific team
Dedicated account-specific team
Product specific team
 
Incident Communication Media
Telephone
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Web
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
E-Mail
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Chat
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
VoIP
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Response Time Varies by Media
Yes
Yes
Yes
 
Software Updates
Advance Update Notification
Included
Included in Prerequisite (Oracle Premier Support)
Included
 
Patches
Included
Included in Prerequisite (Oracle Premier Support)
Included
 
Updates: Minor Releases
Included
Included in Prerequisite (Oracle Premier Support)
Included
 
Upgrades: Major Releases
Included
Included in Prerequisite (Oracle Premier Support)
Included
 
Documentation
Included
Included in Prerequisite (Oracle Premier Support)
Included
 
On-Site Technical Support
Offering Provides On-Site Support
No
Yes
No
 
Quantity of On-Site Support
NA
Offering-dependent
NA
 
Additional Fee or Uplift
NA
Included
NA
 
Travel and Expense Included
NA
No
NA
 
Emergency On-Site Response Time
NA
Offering-dependent
NA
 
Account Management
Account Manager
No
Yes
No
 
Role of Manager
NA
Single point of contact, executive liaison
NA
 
Location
NA
Offering-dependent
NA
 
Dedicated or Shared Resource
NA
Shared
NA
 
Account Manager Account Load
NA
Offering-dependent
NA
 
Number of On-Site Visits
NA
Not limited
NA
 
Entitled Internet-Based Services
Incident Tracking and Status
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Patch Distribution
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Documentation Download
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Access to Knowledge Base
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
System Diagnostic Tools
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Remote Monitoring and Management
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Automated Diagnosis or Self-Healing
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Self-Service Support Web Site
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Software Asset-Tracking Tools
Yes
Yes (included in prerequisite Oracle Premier Support)
Yes
 
Contract Administration Functionality
No
No
No
 
Details of Administration Tools
No
NA
No
 
Service Delivery Performance Reporting
No
Yes
No
 
Details of Reporting Provided
No
Specific details range based on offering provided. Typical reporting includes response and resolution time specifics at detail and summary level
No
 
Frequency of Reporting or Updating
NA
Quarterly
NA
 
On-Site Professional Services
Consulting Service
NA
NA
NA
 
Assessment Service
NA
Yes
NA
 
Deployment Assistance Service
NA
Yes
NA
 
Installation/Upgrade Service
NA
Yes
NA
 
Training and Education
Instructor-Led On-Site
NA
Yes
NA
 
Instructor-Led Vendor Classroom
NA
NA
NA
 
Instructor-Led via Internet
Available periodically
Available periodically
Available periodically
 
Self-Directed via Internet
Available on self-service support site
Available on self-service support site
Available on self-service support site
 
Self-Directed via CD-ROM
NA
NA
NA
 
NA = not applicable
N/A = not available
SLA = service-level agreement
VoIP = voice over Internet Protocol

Source: Gartner (November 2007)

 


 



Table 3. Oracle Software Support Offerings (Part 2)







Offering Name



Enterprise Linux Network Support
(Note 1)



Enterprise Linux Basic Support
(Note 2)



Enterprise Linux Premier Support
(Note 3)
Notes for Enterprise Linux: The Basic and Premier Support offerings for Linux are the same as Oracle's Database support.
 
Oracle Linux Support
 
Pricing Method and Terms
Standard Price of Offering
Calculated on a per-system basis
Calculated on a per-system basis
Calculated on a per-system basis
 
Price Range
$99
$399 and $999 (refer to Notes for Enterprise Linux)
$1,199 and $1999 (refer to Notes for Enterprise Linux)
Annual price per system with up to 2 CPUs is $399 for Basic Support and $1,199 for Premier Support; and Annual Price per system with unlimited CPUs is $999 for Basic support is and $1,999 for Premier Support.
Pricing Method
Refer to Notes for Enterprise Linux.
Refer to Notes for Enterprise Linux.
Refer to Notes for Enterprise Linux.
Calculated on a per-system basis.
1. Annual price per system with up to two physical CPUs.
2. Annual price per system with unlimited physical CPU's
Price Basis
NA
NA
NA
 
Term of Contract
Annual contract
Annual contract
Annual contract
All three Linux support levels have a 1-year or 3-year standard terms.
Available on Per-Call or Per-Incident Basis<